Farmers Market Fall Fantasy—Hot Roasted Chili Polenta

A friend of mine once came up to me at a potluck and exclaimed, “I HATE polenta! But I LOVE it now! Your's was so gooooood!!” That’s because I never make it basic: I never use plain water; I always add aromatic ingredients, and I honestly can’t remember ever making it without some kind of cheese. Once you know how to make a basic polenta, you really can do so much more with it. It becomes its own main dish.

Here’s an impromptu fall polenta dish I created this weekend after buying a bag of hot roasted chilis at the Boise Farmers Market. Kimbal mentioned polenta and that was it. We went straight home after getting pumpkins and I started cooking.

Note... Because of the charred roasted chilis, this polenta isn't as bright yellow as most polenta dishes. Personally, I like it that way because I love anything browned, burnt, fried or toasted. (Just me.)


1. Cooked the aromatics

We bought fresh leeks at the market too so I definitely wanted to use those! I thinly sliced a few small stalks and sauteed them in a cast iron skillet for several minutes in olive oil. (Any aromatic will work here: shallots, red onion, sweet onion, garlic.)

2. Added some hot roasted chilis

I peeled the charred skins from 3 roasted (spicy hot!) chilis with my fingers. (Don't run them under water to remove the charred skins or you’ll lose so much of the precious succulent oils! You want those because they add unctuous flavor to whatever dish you’re making.) Then I thinly sliced them into the leeks.

3. A touch of salt and cumin

I was careful with salting at this point because I knew I’d be using stock that was pre-salted, and cheese, which—depending on the variety—can sometimes be salty or bring out the taste of saltiness in other foods.

4. Added the polenta and brown it a little

I put about a cup of dried polenta into the sauteed leeks and chilis, without adding the stock yet. I just browned the bits a little for a few minutes over medium-high heat to give them a little more flavor. (Why not? Some like everything burnt.)

5. Poured in the stock

A general rule of thumb is 3:1 liquid to dried polenta. (Every polenta variety will require slightly varying amounts of liquid, depending upon how course it’s ground. But you can generally start at 3:1. Sometimes you may need to up it to a 4:1 ratio) I slowly poured in about 2 1/2 cups of chicken stock while stirring, then turned down the heat to medium-low. I made sure to stir frequently so the polenta didn’t clump up as it cooked. I cooked it this way over med-low, stirring frequently, for about 30 minutes. I added small amounts of stock as it cooked, totalling a little more than 3 cups in the end.

6. Soft or hard? Time to choose

Polenta can be served soft like grits, or hard and sliceable. I wanted it hard so I could slice it and plate it. If you want it sliceable, you don't need to do much else. I added a little salted butter for flavor and creaminess, but you can also add a little milk or cream here too—not too much if you want it to keep its form after setting. A quarter cup will be fine.

If you want your polenta soft, you can add a little more stock or milk or cream—½ cup, more or less, depending on how soft you want it. If the polenta is soft and creamy and it’s the consistency you want, it’s done cooking.

7. Added queso fresco, salt and flavors